Fall | 2026
When the Work Becomes Real
"Are they going to be impressed with this? Are you going to just blow their minds?"

It started with an email. Mindy Matthews had never actually met Melany Baldwin or her husband Scott; she knew their Galesburg coffee shop, Orange Cup, mainly as a customer. But Matthews had just returned to the classroom at Lombard Middle School after several years as an instructional coach, and she wanted something different for her fifth-grade English class: something fun, something creative, and most of all, something real. So on September 17, 2024, she sent the Baldwins a proposal. Her students would invent their own Orange Cup drinks, developing flavors, designing visuals, writing advertisements using figurative language and sensory details, and recording video pitches. Would Orange Cup consider looking at a few? Maybe choose one for the menu?
The Baldwins didn't hesitate. As Matthews put it, describing how the couple runs their business generally, "they very rarely say no. I don't think they say no anytime. They're just, yes."
The project took shape quickly. The Baldwins visited Matthews' classes and told their story, and the students got to work brainstorming flavors and names, building visuals in Canva, and writing scripts meant to sell. Matthews gave them a reference point they understood instantly: think Shark Tank. "You want them to pick your drink," she told them. Suddenly, figurative language wasn't an exercise for a test grade; there were real people on the other end who were actually going to read it. Matthews pushed accordingly. "I think you can do better," she'd tell a student. "Go back and try better." Add more detail. Make the pitch land harder. "Are they going to be impressed with this?" she'd ask them. "Are you going to just blow their minds?" There was a real deadline too, and the students who missed it learned something else about the world outside school: the project moved on without them.
When the submissions went to Orange Cup, about 130 of them the second year the program ran, the Baldwins didn't treat the students' ideas any differently than they treat their own staff's. At the shop, Melany and Scott don't design the monthly specialty boards themselves; their baristas do. "We give them full artistic license," Baldwin said. Why should fifth graders be any different? Matthews had originally hoped Orange Cup might feature a couple of student drinks. The Baldwins had a bigger idea: an entire monthly board, eight student-created drinks strong, judged completely blind, with no names attached, just ingredients, visuals, and pitches.
The unveiling turned into its own event. Matthews decorated her classroom to look like Orange Cup, logo and all. When the finished board was revealed, some students needed a moment to even recognize their own drink, since nothing on it carried their name. Then it clicked. That one was theirs. "I think the best part was those kids seeing that their drink had made the board up there," Matthews said.
For Baldwin, the day revealed something about Matthews too. Watching the classroom and the students' reactions, she said, "We saw just the pure joy that I would have as a parent if I had her as a teacher for my child," adding that the students showed "an amazing level of respect for their teacher, because they know that she goes all out and she goes the extra mile." Matthews brushes off praise like that; she'd rather talk about her students, about wanting the best for them, which sometimes looks like encouragement and sometimes looks like telling a kid their draft isn't there yet. "Tough love," she calls it, paired with a standard she holds because she believes they can reach it.
None of it would have happened without a teacher willing to email people she'd never met, a principal willing to say yes, business owners willing to take a classroom full of ideas seriously, and a room full of ten- and eleven-year-olds willing to find out that schoolwork can travel further than the classroom wall. A real business. A real deadline. A real audience. A real menu board. And for eight fifth graders, a genuinely real realization: that one was mine.
