Summer | 2026
Wherever You Land, You're Still Orange and Blue
"We just didn't want to leave our family and leave Newton."

There is no club for this. No membership card, no annual dinner, no plaque on a wall downtown. But ask enough Newton Community High School graduates the same handful of questions, and a pattern starts to surface that none of them quite planned — and all of them, somehow, recognize in each other.
They left, mostly. That part is ordinary; every small town watches its graduates scatter toward colleges and cities and opportunities that don't exist within the county line. What's less ordinary is how many of them came back, and how clearly they remember the moment they decided to.
Brett Tarr never really left at all — chiropractic school in Iowa, then home, married three weeks later, building a practice and a string of car washes two miles from where he grew up. A friend once tried to lure him to Michigan. He didn't go. "We just didn't want to leave our family and leave Newton." Lea Creadore left for design school in St. Louis and built a life she loved there — and had already decided, before she and her husband Matt were even married, that it was temporary. "Why build a career here when we know we're gonna go home?" She wanted her own kids bleeding orange and blue someday, the same colors she'd worn through high school. They do now.
Tim Weber spent four years in Carbondale and most of a decade trading commodities in Kansas City before a six-hour round trip to see family one too many times made the decision for him. Will May circled the globe twice over — Thailand, the coast of Japan after the tsunami, the most contested district of Helmand Province — turned down a path deeper into Special Operations, and came home instead. "I just felt like I was better served to come home." He lives three miles west of where he grew up. He knows the exact direction without checking.
And Paige Webster's homecoming might be the most literal of all. She walked into Dr. Adam Wolf's optometry practice at twelve years old, needing glasses. She'll walk back into that same practice as Dr. Paige Schafer, the appointment having come full circle in a way no one could have scripted. "You are part of the Wolf family," he told her. "You are one of us."
That kind of welcome — extended, in one form or another, to nearly everyone in this group — might be the truest thing Newton alumni share. Not a single industry, not a single career path, but a recurring experience of people who showed up for them without being asked. Tony Weber traces his work ethic to a school bus that hauled teenagers into July cornfields to detassel, a tradition four decades deep, still teaching the same lesson it always did: show up, do the work, don't quit. Jeannie Johnson, who has spent twenty-five years in Jasper County's behavioral health division helping people most of the community will never know she's helped, puts it the simplest way anyone does: "The community's really good about wrapping their arms around you."
It shows up in family businesses that double as community institutions — the Borgics building a print and embroidery shop on the Newton square that now outfits county fairs across the region; the Yemm family's six-decade dealership lineage in a different county over but cut from the same cloth; Taylor Kerner turning down a six-figure offer in Wisconsin because he didn't want to leave Jasper County, then renovating an abandoned furniture building into a hub housing five different local businesses under one roof. It shows up in people who built their whole adult lives around showing up for someone else's worst day, like Lisa Meyer, who lives above the funeral home she and her husband own and run, and who says of the families she serves: "I immerse myself in your life on the worst day and get the highlight reel."
It shows up, too, in something harder to name but easy to feel — a hometown instinct toward gratitude rather than entitlement. Will May, a year sober and rebuilding his life around 6 a.m. Bible study and a detailing business built on attention rather than volume, gets teary-eyed talking about the community that supports him. Brett Tarr closes his own story by thanking God for the courage to walk through open doors and the wisdom to know when to turn around — language that shows up, in different words, again and again across this group.
What connects a chiropractor, a commodity trader turned loan officer, a Marine turned detailer, an optometrist, a funeral director, and a small business builder isn't a shared career or even a shared decade. It's an ethos absorbed somewhere between the hallways and the gymnasium and the fields beyond town: that a place can hold you even after you've left it, that coming home isn't a failure to launch but its own kind of arrival, and that the people who built you don't stop showing up just because you walked across a stage.
There's also a quieter thread running underneath all of it: the way Newton alumni keep finding each other again, years later, in configurations nobody could have predicted. Taylor Kerner's Pioneer district manager was the catcher on the opposing team when Taylor played high school baseball. Tony Weber built his drone business through a partnership that traces back to relationships formed long before either side knew it would matter. Jasper County is small enough that these threads cross constantly, and large enough in spirit that nobody seems to mind.
And then there's what they're building for the next generation, often without fully realizing that's what they're doing. Lea Creadore's nine-year-old son ran his own pop-up bracelet business and watched his hometown show up for him the way it shows up for everyone else. The Borgic kids work the family shop before and after school, absorbing the same lesson their parents learned: that a business and a family can be the same thing, if you let them. Paige Webster will spend her career in the exam room of the man who first fitted her for glasses, becoming the version of him that some future twelve-year-old will trust without quite knowing why.
Ten years out, twenty years out, fifty years out — the road home to Newton keeps getting traveled. Most of them will tell you it was worth every mile.
